The one wine 17 sommeliers always order

Ask a sommelier what they always order and you learn more than from any scorecard. VinePair asked 17 of them which wine they cannot resist when they spot it on a list. Almost none of the answers are famous, and that is the useful part.
The list
VinePair's panel came mostly from New York, with others from Chicago, Boston, Denver, Los Angeles, Paso Robles and the Palm Springs area. Their picks, grouped by country:
- Italy (6): Antinori's Tignanello from Tuscany; Valentini's Cerasuolo d'Abruzzo, a serious rosé; Collecapretta's "Terra dei Preti" from Umbria; a Grignolino from the young Piedmont producer Sette; Elio Sandri's Barolo "Perno" 2020; and Timorasso, the white grape of the hills around Tortona.
- France (5): the Loire Chenin Blanc "Shi Ro" 2018 from Les Jardins de la Martinière; Alice and Olivier de Moor's Aligoté from vines planted in 1902; anything from Alain Castex in Banyuls; Jean Foillard's Morgon "Côte du Py" 2017; and Domaine du Collier in the Loire.
- United States (4, plus one style): Lady of the Sunshine's Chene Vineyard Pinot Noir; Cinsault from the Bechthold Vineyard in Lodi; Jonata's "La Sangre de Jonata" Syrah; Occidental's Freestone-Occidental Pinot Noir 2024; and, as a category, cool-climate Syrah.
- Germany (1): Dr. Ulli Stein's Palmberg Alte Reben Riesling Kabinett Trocken 2021 from the Mosel.
- Australia (1): anything from Mac Forbes in the Yarra Valley.
Three that stand out
Bechthold Vineyard Cinsault, Lodi. Scott Stroemer of Galit in New York chose "not a single bottle, but a single vineyard". It is a good choice. According to the Lodi Winegrape Commission, Joseph Spenker planted these own-rooted vines in 1886, making it Lodi's oldest continuously farmed vineyard of any kind. For decades the grape was sold as "Black Malvoisie", mostly to home winemakers. Several producers now bottle it, including Turley.

Tignanello. The only true blue-chip name on the list. Scott Jones of The Edge Steakhouse in Rancho Mirage said it "helped redefine Italian winemaking", and the producer's own history backs that up. Antinori says Tignanello was the first Sangiovese aged in small barrels and one of the first Chianti Classico reds made without white grapes. The 1971 vintage, released in 1974, was the first to carry the name, and it became one of the original "Super Tuscans".
Timorasso. Scott Thomas of Restaurant Olivia in Denver did not name a bottle at all, just a grape. Timorasso, from the hills around Tortona in Piedmont, is a white with "a bit of red-wine grip and racy acidity". The quality is so consistent, he said, that he will order almost any bottle he sees.
What the answers have in common
Small production comes up again and again. Lady of the Sunshine makes only a few hundred cases of each wine. "Shi Ro" comes from less than a hectare of vines. Several sommeliers said part of the thrill was simply seeing the wine on a list at all. Chris Gellein of Claud in New York compared finding Valentini's rosé to discovering an Easter egg.
Old vines are another theme: the Lodi Cinsault, the de Moor Aligoté from 1902 plantings and Stein's Alte Reben, which means old vines.
And there is a clear lean towards fresh, lighter styles: Aligoté, Grignolino, cool-climate Syrah, Beaujolais and Loire Cabernet Franc, rather than big oaky reds.
Our take
This is the most practical kind of wine list, because it gives you names to look for rather than scores to chase. Most diners scan a wine list for a region they recognise and a price they can bear. The sommelier's trick is to look for producers.
The easiest wins here are the categories, not the bottles. Timorasso, Grignolino, Aligoté and cool-climate Syrah are all styles where an unfamiliar name on a list is likely to be a good bet, and they are usually priced below the famous regions.
Next time you see one of these on a menu, try it. If you are not sure, ask the sommelier what they would order. As this list shows, they rarely say the most expensive bottle.
One caution: several of these wines are made in tiny quantities, and restaurant mark-ups on rare bottles can be steep. The point of a list like this is not to chase the exact bottle. It is to recognise a name, or a grape, when you see one, and to know it is worth a try.
Sources
- VinePair, We asked 17 sommeliers: what's the one wine you always order when you see it on a menu? (November 10, 2026)
- Lodi Winegrape Commission, Ser's Bechthold Cinsaut adds mystique to Lodi's multi-generational wine culture
- Marchesi Antinori, Tignanello: historical data







