Three Palm Island mansions are for sale at $185.5m. The plan is to knock them down

Three mansions, one asking price of $185.5m, and a plan to knock all three down.
A waterfront compound at 190, 198 and 210 Palm Avenue on Palm Island, the gated strip of land off the MacArthur Causeway between Miami and South Beach, is back on the market at $185.5m. That makes it the most expensive listing in Miami Beach. If a buyer pays it, it would be the biggest home sale ever recorded in Miami-Dade County.
The odd part is what is being sold. The three houses are fine. The pitch is to get rid of them.
The pitch
The sellers have commissioned designs from Choeff Levy Fischman Architecture + Design, a Miami firm, for a single house to replace the three existing ones. Their press release describes a three-storey, 30,000 sq ft "Tropical Modern" residence in glass, natural stone and light wood, with 10 bedrooms and 19 bathrooms.
What the renderings promise:
- A waterfall along the back of the house, dropping about 20ft from an infinity-edge pool
- A primary suite of 3,262 sq ft, with its own morning kitchen, spa pool and terrace on the bay
- A car museum with turntables to show off the collection
- A one-and-a-half-storey wellness wing with a gym, massage room, sauna, steam room, hot and cold plunges and a private hair salon
- A cinema, a cigar room, a game room, a chef's kitchen plus a separate staff kitchen, and a rooftop deck
- A lawn running to the seawall and deep-water dockage
"Bringing the three properties together created an opportunity that is extraordinarily difficult to replicate in Miami Beach," said Jorge Luis Garcia, the lead seller, in the release. Paul Fischman, a principal at the architecture firm, said that with roughly 300ft of waterfront "the architecture has an opportunity to behave very differently than it does on a typical Miami Beach lot."
None of it has been built. The buyer gets the land, the three existing houses and a set of drawings.
What is actually there
Miami-Dade's property appraiser has the details. There are three lots of 30,000 sq ft each, just over two acres in total, zoned for single-family estates. The houses on them were built between 2009 and 2016 and have about 35,200 sq ft of heated living space between them.
Two of the three belong to Garcia, a medical entrepreneur who once owned Orlando Family Physicians. County records show he bought 190 Palm Avenue in April 2019 for $13.9m, and that his company JLG Family Holdings bought 198 Palm Avenue in October 2021 for $17m. The third house, at 210, is held by a trust in the name of Adria Almeida, whose late father, the developer Pedro Adrian, built the compound. He bought that lot in 2004 for $3.45m.
Add it up and the three purchases came to $34.35m. The county's 2026 market values for the three houses come to about $66.3m, with the land alone at $16.5m a lot.
The price history
The compound has been on and off the market since 2023.
- Late 2023: $150m for all three, sold only as a package. "If we don't get that number, we're not selling," Juan Miguel Almeida told the Wall Street Journal at the time.
- January 2025: back at $150m, now with Fredrik Eklund of Douglas Elliman. He suggested it could suit "larger families like royals with big staffs and security needs."
- July 2025: trimmed to $148.5m.
- November 2026: $185.5m, $37m more than the last cut, marketed by Garcia's own company, Fortune 500 Enterprises, rather than a big brokerage.
The number to beat
The current Miami-Dade record was set in March. Mark Zuckerberg and Priscilla Chan paid $170m for an unfinished mansion at 7 Indian Creek Island Road, the exclusive enclave known as the Billionaire Bunker. It had been listed at $200m four months earlier. That deal beat the previous county record by $50m: Vlad Doronin's $120m sale on Star Island in 2025.
Florida's record is still the $225m paid for a waterfront estate in Naples. The US record is Ken Griffin's roughly $238m New York apartment in 2019.

Palm Island is not new to big names. The island was dredged out of Biscayne Bay in the early 1920s. In 1928, Al Capone paid $40,000 for a house at 93 Palm Avenue, on the same island, and died there in 1947.
Our take
An asking price is a wish, not a price, and this one has gone up after two years without a buyer. On paper the jump looks steep. The sellers paid $34.35m for the three houses, the county values them at about $66m, and the ask is almost three times that. To get the house in the renderings, the buyer would then have to demolish three perfectly good houses and spend years building a fourth.
But the real pitch is about land. Waterfront on Miami's islands is almost all taken, and the buyers who matter judge it by the foot. Zuckerberg paid about $850,000 for each foot of his 200ft of Indian Creek shoreline, and his house was not finished. At full price, Palm Island works out at about $618,000 a foot for 300ft, on a site of about the same size. Seen that way, $185.5m is less mad than it sounds.
The renderings are there to sell the idea, and the buyer is free to bin them. Anyone spending this much will hire their own architect.
What to watch: whether anyone pays close to the ask. If they do, the Miami-Dade record moves from Indian Creek to Palm Island, and other waterfront owners will try the same trick of combining lots with their neighbours.
Sources
- Miami-Dade County Property Appraiser, property records for 190 Palm Avenue, 198 Palm Avenue and 210 Palm Avenue: owners, sale history, lot sizes, year built, heated area and 2026 market values
- Sellers' press release (Jorge Luis Garcia and Fortune 500 Enterprises, with Choeff Levy Fischman Architecture + Design), as quoted in Mansion Global and the New York Post (November 9 and 10, 2026)
- The Real Deal, Palm Island neighbors combine homes for $150M listing (December 2, 2023), citing the Wall Street Journal
- New York Post, Rare triple-waterfront Miami Beach compound lists for $150M (January 22, 2025)
- Miami Herald, Zuckerberg buys 'Billionaire Bunker' home for $170M (March 4, 2026), citing the multiple listing service
- The Real Deal, Mark Zuckerberg's $170M Indian Creek Island purchase sets Miami-Dade record (March 2, 2026)
- Wikipedia, Palm Island (Miami Beach) and Al Capone (island history, 93 Palm Avenue)
- Renderings: Choeff Levy Fischman Architecture + Design, released with the sellers' press release







