Palm Beach's 'fake Cartier heiress' was turned away from a New York party
Andrea Bartzen was refused entry to MarieBelle's 25th-anniversary party on Broome Street on 16 November, Page Six reported; the organiser said she was not invited.
By The Graze · November 18, 2026 · 3 min read

Society
Andrea Bartzen, the Palm Beach socialite New York media have tagged the "fake Cartier heiress", was turned away from a 25th-anniversary party for the chocolatier MarieBelle at its Broome Street shop on the night of 16 November. The organiser, the publicist Norah Lawlor, told Page Six that Bartzen "wasn't on the guest list, she wasn't invited."
A plus-one that was never approved
A source at the party told Page Six that Bartzen "was trying to convince the publicist to let her in" and was refused. Lawlor, who works in New York and spends her winters in Palm Beach, said she still handed over a goodie bag. "She asked to come back later and I said, 'No. You are not on the list. I will invite you one day when it's appropriate.'" Her rule was short: "Don't go if you're not invited."
Bartzen's account is that she had been asked along as a plus-one. Page Six said it had confirmed that another guest offered to add her, but that the request was never approved. "I went to have a business meeting with someone there who was invited," Bartzen told the paper. "I said please add me as a plus-one and get it confirmed … Norah, the gatekeeper, said 'You didn't RSVP personally,' and so I said 'Fine' and didn't go to the event." She said the guest stepped outside, they had a five-minute meeting, and she left. Invited names at the party, Page Six reported, included the designer Nicole Miller, Keiko Aoki and the lifestyle expert Pamela Morgan.
The name that precedes her
The moniker precedes the door. In March, New York Magazine published "The Fake Cartier and the Fake Rockefeller", a long investigation by Jen Wieczner into Bartzen and a then-boyfriend who introduced himself as Matthew Rockefeller. The magazine reported that, around the time the two met, Bartzen had added Cartier as a middle name on her LinkedIn, and that she told the owners of a Miami yacht club she was an heiress to the jewellery house. It identified the boyfriend as Matthew Wayne Tomasko, a magician from York, Pennsylvania, and said a spokesperson for the American Cancer Society had no record of Global Passion Projects, or of Bartzen or Rockefeller, donating any money after a Hamptons event at which the society had been touted as the beneficiary.
Bartzen has denied the magazine's account. She dismissed it to Page Six as a "hit piece." In an April interview with the Daily Mail, she said, "None of it is true." She has said that Cartier comes from her own family — a pinned Instagram post, the Daily Mail reported, describes her grandmother as Mary Cartier Bartzen — and that she would not litigate the magazine's points one by one. "The fact that I have to justify my existence is not the way I want to tell the story," she said. A spokesperson for New York Magazine told the Daily Mail the story "was deeply reported and carefully fact-checked."
What she will and will not accept
Bartzen told the Daily Mail she had "a completely clean record in every respect" and that the party-crasher-turned-business story was "a complete fallacy." Asked about a black-tie wedding at the Flagler Museum in Palm Beach, which the magazine described her as crashing, she allowed that "some claims" may be "partly true."
The Broome Street evening is smaller than that back catalogue, and better documented in the moment. Lawlor is on the record. Bartzen is on the record. The plus-one was real, and it was never signed off. The goodie bag went out anyway.
Our take
A door list is a dull instrument until someone is standing on the wrong side of it. After a magazine has spent thousands of words on a person's name, the clipboard becomes the whole argument: not whether the profile was fair, but whether the host will take the risk. Lawlor's answer was a goodie bag and a no. Bartzen's was that she had been invited, just not approved. Both can be true, and the party still goes on without her.
That is the social mechanic the magazine piece was really about, minus the yacht and the family names. Access is a guest list, a publicist, and a rule that can be enforced in a doorway on Broome Street in under a minute.
Sources
- Page Six, 'Fake Cartier Heiress' Andrea Bartzen turned away from NYC event, 17 November 2026
- New York Magazine, The Fake Cartier and the Fake Rockefeller, 26 March 2026
- Daily Mail, Hamptons party crasher breaks silence on 'fake' Cartier claims, 17 April 2026







