Napa has too much unsold wine. An old rule could go

For decades, much of Napa has worked like an exclusive club: you need a booking to get in. That could be about to change.
On November 4, Napa County's Planning Commission voted unanimously to recommend scrapping the requirement that many wineries advertise "tours and tastings by appointment only". The Napa Valley Register sat through the meeting. The changes now go to the county Board of Supervisors, which has the final word. No date has been set.
The reason is money. Napa has too much wine and not enough people buying it.
The glut
Silicon Valley Bank's annual State of the US Wine Industry report (SVB is now part of First Citizens Bank), written for years by Rob McMillan, sets out the problem:
- Revenue: $74.3bn in 2025, down from $75.5bn in 2024
- Volume: about 329 million cases, down from 335.9 million
- Inventory: still elevated across the supply chain
"Premium wineries are feeling the tension between holding back the next release or discounting a current slow-moving vintage," McMillan said. In Napa, the downturn has already led to vineyards being left fallow and some wineries facing bankruptcy, the Register reports.
What would change
The headline change is simple. The "appointment only" requirement would be struck from the county code, so wineries could take down the signs and welcome drop-in visitors. They would still be bound by the daily, weekly and annual visitor limits in their individual use permits.
The commission also recommended:
- Bigger micro-wineries: the annual production cap would double from 5,000 to 10,000 gallons, and the limit on average daily car trips would rise from 20 to 40
- Flexible marketing events: wineries would get more freedom to adjust their event plans, provided visitor numbers do not change
- Small practical fixes: easier approval for electric-car chargers and bike racks
Commissioners also agreed to explore an industry request to let wineries grow and sell other farm products, such as cut flowers and jam, without costly permits. Hemp and cannabis would be excluded.
"A tiny baby step"
Nobody at the meeting thought it was enough. "This is a modest step that's going to smooth things out, but we're going to need a lot more to weather this storm we're in the middle of now," said Commissioner Walter Brooks.
Debra Dommen of Treasury Wine Estates called it "a tiny baby step". "We desperately need so much more," she said. She wants more for visitors to do: "We need wellness experiences and we need culinary experiences and need them now. We don't need them in two years."
Caleb Mosley, executive director of the Napa Valley Grapegrowers, said the county is hard to visit on a whim, and praised the shift towards a "welcome-to-Napa mentality". Peter Rumble, chief executive of the Napa County Farm Bureau, put it most bluntly: "We cannot grow grapes if we cannot sell wine."
One vintner, Lee Hudson, wants the county's 1990 winery definition ordinance rewritten from scratch. "I wouldn't even call this a step," he said. "This is just a motion in the right direction."
Why the rule existed
The appointment rule was never about snobbery, or not only. Napa's agricultural preserve, created in 1968, was designed to keep the valley farmland rather than a theme park. Limits on visitors have long been part of how the county keeps traffic down and the focus on farming. That worry has not gone away; residents have long warned of an "agricultural Disneyland", though none of them spoke at this meeting.
Our take
Napa built its brand on scarcity: small lots, high prices and a tasting you had to plan weeks ahead. That worked when demand was rising. It works much less well when sales are falling and the cellars are full.
Letting people walk in is the most obvious fix imaginable, and it is remarkable that it has taken a crisis to get there. It will not solve an oversupply measured in millions of cases. But a valley that wants to sell more wine has to start by letting more people taste it, and a sign on the gate saying "by appointment only" is a poor way to say hello.
Sources: Napa Valley Register; Napa County Planning Commission, 4 November 2026; Vinetur; Inc.







