A lost O'Keeffe turned up under fur coats in a Manhattan closet

For about 40 years, one of Georgia O'Keeffe's early New Mexico landscapes was in a Manhattan hall closet, in its original box, behind a row of fur coats. Next week it goes to auction with an estimate of $3m to $5m.
Christie's New York will offer the painting, Near Abiquiu, New Mexico I, in its 20th Century Evening Sale on November 17. The work is on public view at 20 Rockefeller Center through the sale. It is the rare art-world find that is exactly as good as it sounds.

The painting
O'Keeffe first went to New Mexico in 1929. She painted Near Abiquiu, New Mexico I the following year. It is long and narrow, 10 by 24 inches, of warm earth tones and soft, rippling hills, and it is thought to be the first of three paintings of Lobo Peak in the north of the state. The second belongs to the Metropolitan Museum of Art; the third is in a private collection.
"O'Keeffe goes to New Mexico in 1929, and this picture is from 1930, so it's the ground floor of her inspiration at that time," Tylee Abbott, head of American art at Christie's New York, told CBS News.
For the art world, the painting had effectively not existed for decades. Its only record was a single 1931 photograph by O'Keeffe's husband, the photographer Alfred Stieglitz. O'Keeffe's catalogue raisonné, the complete scholarly list of her known works, includes it in an addendum marked "unlocated".
The aunt
It was bought in 1963 by a young woman as a graduation present from her parents, directly from O'Keeffe's New York dealer, for $3,800, roughly $42,000 in today's money. She went on to a career in the Foreign Service and became a world-ranked bridge player.
She hung it in her New York apartment for more than two decades. Then, one day in the mid-1980s, in the middle of a bridge game, she noticed a guest looking at it a little too closely. She took it down, put it back in its original box and hid it in the entry closet behind the fur coats. It stayed there.
"I think she was fully aware of its value," her niece, who asked to be identified only by her middle name, Betsy, told the Post. "She disliked drawing attention to herself."
The niece
Betsy only learned of the painting in 2022, when she was helping her aunt prepare the apartment for home health aides. "That's when she mentioned, 'Oh, by the way, there's a Georgia O'Keeffe in the hall closet,'" she said. She did not actually see it until a few weeks ago, when she returned to help her aunt, who has since died, prepare for hospice care.
Her reaction was suitably understated. "I thought, 'Wow. That's pretty wild.'"
How Christie's knew
Authentication relied on two things. The first was the Stieglitz photograph, which let specialists match the composition. The second was on the back: O'Keeffe's distinctive looping signature inside a star-shaped design. Christie's also compared brushwork and style with other O'Keeffes it has handled.
"To uncover a seminal work... is a once-in-a-lifetime moment and absolutely thrilling," Abbott said.
The painting is on public view at Christie's New York through November 17 and will be offered that evening in the 20th Century Evening Sale.
Our take
It is tempting to see the closet as a tragedy, 40 years of a masterpiece in the dark. It was more like a conservator's dream. A painting kept boxed, away from sunlight and smoke, can be in far better condition than one that has hung on a wall for the same time, and Christie's describes this one as well preserved.
The return on $3,800 is the other headline. At the low estimate, it is a gain of nearly 800 times in 63 years. But the aunt never sold, and by Betsy's account never cared to. She bought a painting she loved, then protected it from a nosy bridge partner.
There are surely more like it. Most catalogues raisonnés have an "unlocated" section, and every one of those entries is a closet somewhere.
Sources: Christie's press release; Christie's lot page; New York Post; CBS News; Smithsonian magazine







