Spies have used romance for more than a century. Now the approach often starts on LinkedIn

Intelligence services worked out long ago that the quickest way to a secret is often through a person's ego, loneliness or love life. The method, the honeypot or honey trap, has a long paper trail in archives, parliamentary records and court files. Today it often starts with a friendly message from a profile that does not exist.
Canada's intelligence service, CSIS, spells out the classic version in its travel security guide. A honey trap uses an attractive person, chosen to suit the target, to draw them into a compromising position where they can be blackmailed or publicly embarrassed, often with a hidden recording. Most approaches, the guide says, are quieter: flattery, shared interests and the slow cultivation of a relationship.
The dancer who was not much of a spy
The name everyone knows is Mata Hari. Born Margaretha Zelle in the Netherlands in 1876, she became a famous dancer in Paris. The French arrested her in February 1917, tried her before a military court that July and executed her by firing squad on October 15, 1917.
The British files tell a smaller story. MI5's file on her, KV 2/1 at The National Archives, shows British officers questioned her and kept her under watch. When French intelligence asked her to spy for France, she demanded a million francs. After interviewing her in 1916, the British concluded that if she was a spy at all she was an ineffective amateur. They learned of her execution from the newspapers.
The clerk in Moscow
John Vassall is the textbook case of the trap itself. He was clerk to the naval attaché at the British Embassy in Moscow from March 1954 to July 1956. The National Archives describes how he was caught in a KGB honeytrap, blackmailed into passing secrets, and then began taking payments. Lord Carrington, then First Lord of the Admiralty, told the House of Lords in October 1962 that from the time Vassall was "suborned in Moscow" he "removed, photographed and disclosed certain classified documents".
That was work for cameras like the Minox B above, made from 1958 to 1972, which the CIA says could take excellent photographs of documents at close range. Vassall was arrested on September 12, 1962, and sentenced to 18 years.
The affair that leaked nothing
The Profumo affair is the most famous British case, and the least like a spy story. John Profumo, the Secretary of State for War, met Christine Keeler at a house party at Cliveden in July 1961. Another guest was Yevgeny Ivanov, an attaché at the Soviet Embassy. On March 22, 1963, Profumo told the House of Commons: "There was no impropriety whatsoever in my acquaintanceship with Miss Keeler."
On June 4 he wrote to the prime minister, Harold Macmillan, admitting that statement was untrue: "I misled you, and my colleagues, and the house." He resigned office and his seat. Lord Denning's inquiry, published that autumn, concluded there had been no security risk. Macmillan resigned in October 1963.
The Marine at the embassy
The cleanest American case is in a court record. Sergeant Clayton Lonetree was a Marine guard at the US Embassy in Moscow when, in the words of the Court of Military Appeals, he "met Soviet agent Violetta Seina in a subway station" and began a romantic relationship. He passed confidential information to a Soviet handler, continuing after a transfer to Vienna. A court-martial convicted him of espionage in August 1987 and sentenced him to 30 years, a term later reduced.
The modern version is a message
In April 2021 MI5 said at least 10,000 UK nationals had been approached by fake profiles linked to hostile states on a professional networking site over five years. In May 2022 its director general, Ken McCallum, said foreign spies were "actively working to build relationships with those working in government, in high-tech business and in academia." By October 2023 he put the number approached by suspected Chinese agents at more than 20,000.
Not every modern case involves romance. On January 13, 2022, MI5 issued an interference alert about the solicitor Christine Lee, emailed to all parliamentarians by the Speaker, saying she had knowingly engaged in political interference on behalf of the Chinese Communist Party's United Front Work Department, including by facilitating donations to politicians. On December 17, 2024, the Investigatory Powers Tribunal dismissed her challenge and found MI5 had acted lawfully, while noting there had been no authoritative finding that she had committed a crime. The currency in that case was money and access, not affection.
What organisations do now
CSIS tells travellers to get a country briefing from a security officer, to carry clean devices that are wiped on return, to meet visitors in the hotel lobby rather than the room, and to be wary of offers of companionship. The UK's National Protective Security Authority runs Think Before You Link, built on four steps: recognise a suspicious profile, realise the threat, report it, and remove it.
The timeline
| When | Case | The approach | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1915–1917 | Mata Hari | Agreed to inform for Germany, then for France | Executed by France, October 15, 1917 |
| 1954–1962 | John Vassall | KGB blackmail in Moscow | Arrested 1962; 18 years |
| 1961–1963 | Profumo affair | Minister and Soviet attaché in one social circle | Resigned June 1963; Denning found no security risk |
| Mid-1980s | Clayton Lonetree | Relationship with a Soviet agent in Moscow | Convicted 1987; 30 years, later reduced |
| 2021 | MI5 warning | At least 10,000 fake-profile approaches in five years | Think Before You Link campaign |
| 2022–2024 | Christine Lee alert | Donations and access, no romance | Alert ruled lawful, December 2024 |
| 2023 | MI5 at Five Eyes summit | 20,000+ covert online approaches | Warning to businesses |
Our take
The honeypot is famous for the wrong reasons. The cases in the files are rarely about seduction alone; they work on vanity and loneliness. Vassall was a junior clerk far from home. Lonetree was a young guard in a hostile city. The most famous scandal of all, Profumo, leaked nothing according to the official inquiry; the damage came from the lie told to Parliament.
The modern approach is flattery at scale: a recruiter with a perfect profile, a consultancy offer, an invitation to speak abroad. MI5's published count went from at least 10,000 in 2021 to more than 20,000 in 2023, and those are the ones it knows about. The target is rarely just the chief executive. CSIS notes that something as dull as an organisation chart can be a key requirement for a hostile service. The assistant and the engineer have access too.
The practical lesson is cheap. Treat unexpected warmth from a stranger with the same caution as an unexpected invoice. Brief people before they travel, give them clean devices, and make reporting an approach routine rather than embarrassing.
What to watch: whether MI5's count keeps climbing, and whether other governments copy Britain in publicly naming people they believe act for foreign states, a step the tribunal has confirmed MI5 can lawfully take.
Sources
- The National Archives, Mata Hari, MI5 file KV 2/1 and History of Government blog, Mata Hari: the execution of an alleged international spy-mistress
- The National Archives, John Vassall: victim, spy, traitor, prisoner
- Hansard, The Vassall case and naval security, House of Lords, October 31, 1962
- Hansard, Personal statement by John Profumo, House of Commons, March 22, 1963
- UK Parliament, Lord Denning's report into the Profumo affair
- The Guardian archive, Profumo admits lie and resigns seat in parliament (June 6, 1963)
- US Court of Military Appeals, United States v. Lonetree, 35 M.J. 396 (1992)
- Investigatory Powers Tribunal, Lee and Wilkes v Security Service (December 17, 2024)
- GOV.UK, New app to counter malicious approaches online (May 17, 2022)
- National Protective Security Authority, Think Before You Link
- Canadian Security Intelligence Service, Far From Home: a travel security guide
- BBC News, MI5 warns of spies using LinkedIn to trick staff into spilling secrets (April 2021) and MI5 head warns of 'epic scale' of Chinese espionage (October 2023)
- Wikipedia, Clayton J. Lonetree (conviction date)
- Photo: Central Intelligence Agency, Minox B camera, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
- Timeline: The Graze, from the sources above







